top of page

New Haven Pizza & Italian Food

Restaurants that serve Italian food and pizza in New Haven, CT

photo credit: @frankpepepizza

Frank Pepe Pizza

157 Wooster St

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana is arguably the world's most famous pizza spot in the Italian district of New Haven. They're famous for their thin crust pies and specialty white clam, which won the title of "Best Pizza in America"

photo credit: @the_roamingfoodie

Goodfellas

702 State St

Old-school mobster-themed Italian eatery in a cozy storefront with brick walls & white tablecloths

photo credit: @infonewhaven

L'Orcio

806 State St

Modern Italian cuisine, including fresh pasta, served in a townhouse with a trellis-covered patio.

photo credit: @eatsleepfoodct

Marco Polo Pizzeria & Italian

55 Crown St

Low-key pizza parlor offering creative pies, pasta & panini, plus veggie & gluten-free options.

photo credit: @michelinas_858statest

Michelina's Apizza and Ristorante

858 State St

Authentic Italian recipes and wood fired apizza from a couple who have been in the business since ’87 (and were both born in Italy).

photo credit: @modernapizza

Modern Pizza

874 State St

Modern Apizza, located on State Street, was founded in 1934 and has been in the same spot ever since. Modern serves New Haven-style thin-crust apizza and uses an oil-fueled brick oven.

Photo credit: @newwestcafenh

New West Cafe

879 Whalley Avenue

Local bar and restaurant serving italian food, classic sandwiches, subs and burgers. Solid collection of draft beers.

photo credit: @nextdoornhv

Next Door

175 Humphrey St

Douglas Coffin, founder of Big Green Truck Pizza, saw an opportunity in the old Humphrey's location to bring back some of that neighborly feeling, drawing on his own diverse New Haven experiences. Thus, Next Door was born!

photo credit: @eatwithanaxo

Olives & Oil New Haven

124 Temple St

Creative Italian cuisine & brick-oven pizza, with hand-pulled mozzarella, in a brick-walled setting.

Photo credit: @one6threect

One 6 Three

163 Foster St

Creative Neapolitan-style pizzas are the draw at this snug, modern joint with a vibrant atmosphere.

Featured

FEATURED

Pepe's Pizza

Voted best pizza in America for their white clam pie.

Frank Pepes _frankpepepizza.jpg

photo credit: @frankpepepizza

FEATURED

Adriana's

Both Northern & Southern Italian fare are served among earth-toned walls & paintings.

Adriana's my own pic.jpg

photo credit: @supnewhaven

Alphabetical List

bottom of page